The short answer

I'd compare Omnisend for a store-focused alternative, Brevo for a different sending-cost model, and Drip or ActiveCampaign when automation is the main concern. Mailchimp is worth a look for wider marketing work. I'd price your actual list and messages before calling any of them cheaper.

A rising email bill is a fair reason to look around. Before moving, though, I'd want to know whether the problem is the price itself or paying for things the team doesn't use.

Write down the audience you pay for, campaign sends, automated messages, SMS use, and the flows you want to keep. That's the setup the replacement needs to match. A low starting price won't tell you whether moving it all is worthwhile.

Research-based recommendations. Startup Stacked is free to use, with no paid plans or upgrade fees. Third-party tools may charge separately. Our editorial approach.

At a glance

USD where a dollar price is shown. Annual equivalents require the stated commitment. Taxes, usage, and optional services may be additional.

Options, practical fit, and pricing basis
OptionConsider it forPricing basis
OmnisendAn ecommerce-focused replacement trialFree: up to 250 unique recipients and 500 emails/month
BrevoA sending-volume-led comparisonFree includes 300 sends/day; paid tiers and contact limits vary
DripA focused email-automation evaluationUse the current subscriber calculator for a quote
ActiveCampaignA wider automation requirementTier and contact-based pricing; obtain a workload-specific quote
MailchimpA broader marketing programFree and paid options; contact limits, sends, and promotions vary

The shortlist, explained

Here’s why I’d consider each option, and what I’d check before paying.

An ecommerce-focused replacement trial

Omnisend

I'd start with Omnisend if you want to keep an ecommerce-focused setup. Rebuild one important flow and check it against actual store events. Price it for your current audience and a realistic next stage, rather than judging it from the free tier.

Check before choosing: Contact storage and the number of people you can send to are different limits.

Omnisend logo
OmnisendAn ecommerce-focused replacement trial
Explore Omnisend →Publisher details ↗

A sending-volume-led comparison

Brevo

Brevo's different cost structure is worth working through if a large stored audience doesn't mean frequent sends. I'd still check the store data and automations you rely on. A lower sending bill won't help if you lose a job the current system handles.

Check before choosing: Daily sending caps can prevent a whole-list campaign from going out at once.

Brevo logo
BrevoA sending-volume-led comparison
Explore Brevo →Publisher details ↗

A focused email-automation evaluation

Drip

I'd try Drip with an important campaign you already run. Rebuild its segment rules and exclusions, then see what carries across cleanly. I wouldn't assume every event or filter has an exact equivalent.

Check before choosing: Budget migration time and verify current integration behavior.

Drip logo
DripA focused email-automation evaluation
Explore Drip →Publisher details ↗

A wider automation requirement

ActiveCampaign

I'd look at ActiveCampaign when the automation needs go beyond ordinary store campaigns. Map the actions and branches you need, then check the plan that includes them. Someone also needs time to maintain what you build.

Check before choosing: Entry-tier automation limits may require an upgrade.

ActiveCampaign logo
ActiveCampaignA wider automation requirement
Explore ActiveCampaign →Publisher details ↗

A broader marketing program

Mailchimp

Mailchimp would be on my list if email is part of a broader marketing setup. I'd test the Shopify connection and the automations that matter before choosing a tier. Recognizing the name isn't a reason to assume the cheapest plan does the job.

Check before choosing: Separate promotional pricing, trial access, and ongoing plan limits.

Mailchimp logo
MailchimpA broader marketing program
Explore Mailchimp →Publisher details ↗
A practical decision path
  1. 1Price the same workload
  2. 2Rebuild one important flow
  3. 3Migrate consent and exclusions

Model three audience sizes

I'd price today's audience, a plausible six-month audience, and a larger case. Use the same campaign frequency and include automated sends and extra channels. Check whether inactive or unsubscribed records count toward each provider's bill.

An illustrative 2,000-person list receiving four campaigns generates 8,000 campaign sends before welcome messages and other flows. A provider’s 5,000-send allowance would not cover that schedule, even if its contact limit did. Use your own figures in the same calculation.

Move consent and exclusions with the list

Consent and exclusions need to move with the list. Move subscription status, suppressed addresses, and the fields behind your segments. People who opted out should stay opted out.

Keep the original system available while you validate a small test segment. Check one new signup, one unsubscribe, and the key order-triggered events. Then ensure only one provider sends each automated message during the transition.

  • Map custom fields and segment rules.
  • Preserve opt-outs and suppressed addresses.
  • Authenticate the new sending setup.
  • Test important flows before moving the full schedule.

When staying is the better choice

If the current setup works and the saving is small, I'd try simplifying the account first. Look at unused features, inactive automations, and list management. Moving is more convincing when it solves a problem that keeps coming back.

Ask the person who runs email to participate in the trial. Ease of use depends on the real operator, not only on a screenshot of the campaign builder.

Decide whether the move is worth the work

Before comparing monthly bills, I'd list what has to move: forms, journeys, integrations, fields, exclusions, and the people maintaining them. Include time for test signups and unsubscribes. That work belongs in the comparison too.

Use a simple illustrative payback check. If a move costs $240 in labor and saves $20 each month, subscription savings alone take 12 months to recover that labor. A better workflow could still justify the move, but name that benefit separately rather than hiding the migration cost.

For a first email platform, there may be little migration work. For an established store, a small price difference may not justify changing a system the team understands. Compare your stage of business as well as your list size.

My recommendation

Where I’d start

I'd move if the replacement handles your important messages and makes the cost or everyday work meaningfully better. If it only looks cheaper on the first pricing-page tier, I'd keep investigating before rebuilding the whole email setup.

Sources & approach

These recommendations are based on the publishers’ documented features and pricing, reviewed September 10, 2026. They aren’t results from hands-on benchmark tests. Check the selected plan before buying; prices and availability can change.

Examples and suggested evaluation thresholds are illustrative. Tell us if something needs correcting.

Written by Jake C