The short answer

I'd only move away from Shopify if I could name the problem the replacement needs to solve. WooCommerce offers a WordPress route, Wix and Squarespace suit broader websites, Square is worth comparing for an existing in-person business, and BigCommerce is another commerce-focused option. A smaller subscription bill is only part of the decision.

Before looking for a replacement, I'd ask what's bothering you: the bill, the editor, a missing feature, or the apps you've ended up maintaining. You can spend a lot of time moving a store and still have the same problem afterward.

I've kept this to eight options with different reasons to consider them. If Shopify already handles your orders well, I'd look for subscriptions you can remove before taking on a rebuild.

Research-based recommendations. Startup Stacked is free to use, with no paid plans or upgrade fees. Third-party tools may charge separately. Our editorial approach.

At a glance

USD where a dollar price is shown. Annual equivalents require the stated commitment. Taxes, usage, and optional services may be additional.

Options, practical fit, and pricing basis
OptionConsider it forPricing basis
WooCommerceControl over a WordPress storefrontFree core; separate hosting and extensions
WixA service or content business adding a storePaid ecommerce plan
SquarespaceA focused, design-led product collectionPaid plan; check applicable selling fees
BigCommerceA commerce-focused platform comparisonCore: $39/month on monthly billing
SquareAn existing Square merchant selling onlineFree and paid options; processing fees apply
EcwidAdding commerce to an existing websitePaid tiers; check catalog and feature limits
Big CartelAn artist or maker with a small collectionFree and paid plans with product limits
WebflowA design-led site with developer involvementEcommerce site plan; distinguish workspace charges

The shortlist, explained

Here’s why I’d consider each option, and what I’d check before paying.

Control over a WordPress storefront

WooCommerce

I'd look at WooCommerce if WordPress control is the reason you want to move. I'd also want a name beside backups, updates, and testing changes. More control is useful when someone has the time and knowledge to look after it.

Check before choosing: Include technical labor in the comparison.

WooCommerce logo
WooCommerceControl over a WordPress storefront
Explore WooCommerce →Publisher details ↗

A service or content business adding a store

Wix

Wix is worth trying if your business needs a website with a store, rather than a site built mainly around products. I'd test services, enquiries, and sales together. Moving would need to make those regular jobs easier.

Check before choosing: Verify integrations for subscriptions and fulfillment.

Wix logo
WixA service or content business adding a store
Explore Wix →Publisher details ↗

A focused, design-led product collection

Squarespace

Squarespace makes sense to me for a smaller collection supported by good photos and useful pages. Put your actual product options into the trial. A polished template won't tell you whether an unusual checkout requirement will work.

Check before choosing: Confirm product-type fees and export options.

Squarespace logo
SquarespaceA focused, design-led product collection
Explore Squarespace →Publisher details ↗

A commerce-focused platform comparison

BigCommerce

I'd give BigCommerce a look when Shopify isn't meeting a specific commerce requirement. Get a total for your sales volume and payment provider using the updated 2026 fees. I wouldn't base a move on an old comparison chart.

Check before choosing: Do not rely on old claims about plan names or additional provider fees.

BigCommerce logo
BigCommerceA commerce-focused platform comparison
Explore BigCommerce →Publisher details ↗

An existing Square merchant selling online

Square

If you're already using Square in person, that's a good reason to try its online setup. I'd check stock, pickup, and the work your staff do each day. Those connections would matter more to me than a free-plan headline.

Check before choosing: Availability and features vary by market and plan.

Square logo
SquareAn existing Square merchant selling online
Explore Square →Publisher details ↗

Adding commerce to an existing website

Ecwid

I'd consider Ecwid if the website you have is worth keeping and you mainly need to add a store. Start with that existing site and the number of products you need. There's no need to rebuild good pages just to change how people buy.

Check before choosing: Check which tier unlocks your required sales channels.

Publisher details ↗

An artist or maker with a small collection

Big Cartel

For a small collection, I'd be quite happy to consider a smaller storefront. Big Cartel belongs in that conversation if it covers the selling jobs you need. I'd check the product limits before spending time importing anything.

Check before choosing: Check product limits before importing the catalog.

Publisher details ↗

A design-led site with developer involvement

Webflow

Webflow would be on my list if control over the site design was the reason for leaving. I'd involve whoever will maintain it from the start. The design freedom needs to work alongside the checkout and integrations you depend on.

Check before choosing: Check ecommerce limits and transaction charges separately from workspace pricing.

Webflow logo
WebflowA design-led site with developer involvement
Explore Webflow →Publisher details ↗
A practical decision path
  1. 1Name the problem
  2. 2Prove the replacement works
  3. 3Move with a rollback plan

Write down the reason for leaving

I'd finish this sentence before opening another trial: 'I want to leave because…' A high app bill, an awkward editor, and a missing selling feature need different fixes. Naming the problem makes it easier to rule options out.

Give the replacement a pass/fail test. For example: “We need local pickup and online stock to reconcile without a spreadsheet.” A candidate that fails that task is not a bargain, even if its homepage looks better.

Plan the migration before canceling anything

Plan the move while the old store is still working. Export the product and customer records, list the important URLs, and find out what won't transfer automatically. Then test redirects, taxes, order emails, refunds, and fulfillment before canceling anything.

Recurring payments and customer passwords deserve particular attention: do not assume they can be exported and re-created like product descriptions. Confirm the supported migration path with the providers before changing an active subscription business.

  • Inventory integrations and recurring subscriptions.
  • Map important URLs and search landing pages.
  • Test checkout and refunds with the supported test tools.
  • Move only when the replacement workflow is complete.

My recommendation

Where I’d start

I'd stay put unless a trial shows that the replacement solves the reason you wanted to leave. There's nothing wrong with keeping Shopify and cutting a few unnecessary apps. Moving the whole store should have a clearer payoff than a slightly nicer starting price.

Sources & approach

These recommendations are based on the publishers’ documented features and pricing, reviewed September 10, 2026. They aren’t results from hands-on benchmark tests. Check the selected plan before buying; prices and availability can change.

Examples and suggested evaluation thresholds are illustrative. Tell us if something needs correcting.

Written by Jake C